Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta Phase I - Interviews (Lean Roadmap). Mostrar todas as mensagens
Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta Phase I - Interviews (Lean Roadmap). Mostrar todas as mensagens

sábado, 6 de julho de 2013

L#6 – The goal of talking to advisors is identifying your riskiest assumptions

I. SUMMARY

By now you should have taken your business model as far as you can or should on paper.

Yes, I know you can continue brainstorming possibilities. But endlessly brainstorming possibilities grounded in uncertainty is a recipe for failure.

It's time to get outside the building and gather empirical evidence from people other than yourself.

The first conversations I recommend you have aren't with customers. That will come shortly. But with trusted advisors.

These don't have to be "professional" advisors. They can be a prototypical customer, a potential investor, or another fellow entrepreneur with specific expertise, domain knowledge, or experiential knowledge that applies to you.

The goal for these conversations is identifying your riskiest assumptions.

Remember your business model is "the product" you are building. When building a complicated product under a deadline, you wouldn't start with what's easiest, but what's riskiest.

The same principle applies here. Incorrect prioritization of risk is one of the top contributors of waste.

But before you can correctly prioritize risks, you have to first understand the difference between risk and uncertainty.

Things on your canvas have varying levels of uncertainty. But high uncertainty does not necessarily mean high risk.

II. WATCH THIS VIDEO - This video will:
* start with a definition of risk,
* show you how to prioritize risk, and then
* walk you through techniques for honing in on what's riskiest in your model.

 III: LESSON - Startups Are Risky Business.
A key message is recognizing your business model, not your product, as the true product of your startup.
Thinking this way is quite empowering as it allows you to apply similar techniques for building and testing your business model as you would to any product.

One of these is tackling the riskiest parts of your business model first.

Building a successful startup is fundamentally about risk mitigation or in marketing speak: “removing all objections”.

How to Prioritize Risk

A critical first step is prioritizing what’s riskiest on your business model right now.
Otherwise, it’s easy to fall into the trap of making marginal progress only to get stuck later.
Incorrect prioritization of risk is one of the top contributors of waste.

For instance, I used to advocate jumping right into customer interviews after “Documenting your Plan A” (Generating the Business Model) but customers don’t always have all the answers and/or getting these answers can take too long. Not to mention, you might be targeting too broad a customer segment, too small a customer segment, or the wrong customer segment all together.

Instead, I recommend spending a little more time upfront prioritizing risks and brainstorming alternative models with people other than customers – aka advisors. Advisors help you identify risks on the “total plan”, while customers mostly care about their problems only.

Note: These advisors may be potential customers but they tend to fall into the “visionary customer” camp. For example, they might be startup founders themselves.

 Top 3 Universal Risks

While what is riskiest on your model will vary by the type of product you’re building, I’ve found some risks to be universal. Whenever I’m evaluating a new product idea or advising another startup, I always start by evaluating their business model against these three risks:



1. Problem
Top on the list is the risk of building something nobody wants. You not only have to be able to clearly articulate the top problems from a customer viewpoint, but you also need to have a clear definition of who the early adopters are and how they solve these problems today (existing alternatives).

2. Channels
Failing to build a significant path to customers is what kills most products. The more specific your early adopter definition, the easier it is to define channels to reach those customers. I usually find startups in the opposite camp – too broad a segment and no clear way to reach them.

3. Revenue Streams
And finally a business model without revenue is not a business. Even though you may choose to defer charging out of the gate, you need to be able to articulate how you intend to build a business over time. Whatever your revenue model, you HAVE to know how you will sustain your product development effort until then – through customer revenues, savings, external funding, etc.

What About Solution Risk?
Unless you are trying to solve a particularly hard technical problem (like finding a cure for cancer, or building the next big search algorithm), you will be able to build your product given enough time, money, and effort. The bigger risk is building something nobody wants. I focus on “finding problems worth solving” before worrying too much over feasibility.

How to Tackle Risk
Because the terrain before Product/Market Fit is riddled with qualitative learning, you may be able to mitigate but never completely eliminate any of these risks through a single experiment alone. Instead you need to consciously string together a series of experiments (into an iteration) and systematically eliminate these risks over time.

 

L#5 - Going out of the building - where to start first? Advisors to validate your initial Business Model


First remember: the “business model” is the real product of a startup.

As entrepreneurs, we’ve got the solution covered but need help with the rest of the business model to avoid chasing after solutions no one cares about which is a form of waste.



You build your Business Model through a series of conversations with other people that complement your own worldview – advisors, customers, partners, investors, even competitors.

“Customers don’t care about your solution.
They care about their problems.”
- Dave McClure
, 500 Startups

Customer Development is one such conversation where customers complement your worldview on Problem and Solution. Validating you have a problem worth solving (Problem/Solution Fit) is one of the riskier parts of the model you need to tackle early.

Right Action, Right Time

Too often though, entrepreneurs engage in the wrong conversation at the wrong time which also leads to waste. Like talking to investors before customers, prematurely seeking distribution partners, or paying too much attention to competitors.

Investors don’t care about your solution or your customers.
They care about the scalability of your business model.

The order of these conversations is largely driven by the stage of your startup. Before Product/Market Fit, the focus should be centered around learning. During this stage, I find it most productive to surround myself with customers and advisors.

After Product/Market Fit, the focus then shifts to growth. That’s when you stand to reap the biggest impact with investors and partners – especially if you’re converting them from existing customers and/or advisors.

Customer Discovery can still lead to waste

I used to advocate jumping right into customer interviews after “Step 1: Document your Plan A” (generate your Business Model – Lean Canvas) but customers don’t always have all the answers or finding the answers can take too long. Remember, they mostly care about their problems.

While I agree that Customer Discovery should be among the first conversations to initiate, prematurely jumping into customer interviews can still lead to waste for the following reasons:

1. There are many possible Customer Segments to tackle

For a given problem/solution, there may be a large number of possible customer segments, each representing different business models with varying suitability given your unique perspective and resources.

One of my earlier products, BoxCloud, was built around solving the large file sharing problem. This could easily have been targeted at graphic designers, accountants, lawyers, doctors, architects, etc. Each of these could be a startup of it’s own. One approach to vetting early models is taking a broad sweep first but that still takes time to do and time is your most valuable asset.

2. Waiting is the biggest source of waste

Apart from the time it takes to conduct the actual interviews, a lot of time is spent finding prospects and coordinating these interviews. The biggest contributor of waste during this stage is simply waiting for scheduling responses.

Tip: Consider outsourcing interview scheduling and batching them together.

3. Qualitative learning is not perfect

Ironically, qualitative feedback is most effective when it’s overwhelmingly negative. A strong negative signal indicates that your assumptions most likely won’t work and lets you quickly abandon or refine it. If 5 out 5 customers tell you they don’t have a problem, that’s pretty significant!

On the other hand, a strong positive signal doesn’t necessarily mean it will scale or that the customer isn’t lying. All it does is give you permission to move forward until that can be verified later through quantitative data.

Most of the learning during this stage, however, falls somewhere in the middle.

When following a Customer Discovery process, it’s quite possible to interview 30-50 people, get a strong must-have problem signal, build a MVP, refine first user experience, even get some happy paying customers, and still hit a wall because you can’t effectively reach more customers after that.

While Customer Discovery can help you build the right solution for a given customer segment, you may not be addressing other risks in your model.

Business Model Discovery

A lot of these problems can be alleviated by adding another step before Customer Discovery. Rather than jumping into customer interviews, which can take about 4-10 weeks to complete, I now spend a little more time brainstorming and prioritizing the best “possible models” with advisors first – a process I’ll fittingly call “Business Model Discovery”.

I use the term advisor rather loosely. An early advisor might be a prototypical customer/entrepreneur, potential investor, other entrepreneur, even your spouse or significant other. Even though these models are a collection of untested assumptions, they should at least “work on paper” and be something you can clearly articulate to someone (anyone) other than yourself.

Reasonably smart people can rationalize anything but entrepreneurs are especially gifted at this.

Unlike Customer Discovery, where you systematically start testing parts of the business model – notably Problems and Customer Segments, Business Model Discovery is about tackling the entire business model. The goal of both is learning and not pitching.

The first objective is taking a reality check on your possible models. After I made a declaration to follow a Lean Startup/Customer Development process with my last product, CloudFire, I spent a day filling out the first three hypotheses worksheets at end of Steve Blank’s book. I then sat down to review them with my wife, Sasha, who was also going to be customer #1. I scheduled only an hour because I had anticipated breezing through these worksheets. It took us 2 hours just to get through the first worksheet.

What seemed obvious to me represented “leaps of faith” that weren’t obvious to her. Worse, I had nothing to back them up other than “I just know them to be true”. You need someone on your side who isn’t afraid to call bullshit.

Beyond these early “reality-check” advisors, also seek out advisors that bring specific perspective through domain knowledge and/or experience. For instance, before doing any customer interviews on my latest product initiative USERcycle (“KISSmetrics meets MailChimp”), I met with Hiten Shah, Jason Cohen, Joshua Baer, Manuel Rosso, and Eric Ries. Their collective feedback helped inform my decision to pursue a very specific business model over others.

The Goal is Learning

Much like customer interviews aren’t about asking customers what they want, these interviews aren’t about asking advisors what to do.

The Advisor Paradox: Hire advisors for good advice but don’t follow it, apply it.
- Venture Hacks

After documenting your Plan A, Step 2 is identifying the riskiest parts of the model. This is what you need to learn at this stage. We are good at identifying technical risk but need help doing the same with other components of the business model.

The key is not taking this feedback as “judgement or validation” but as a way to identify and prioritize risk. Then move on to Step 3 and tackle that risk through experiments.

Success is unlocked at the intersection of these conversations and it’s your job as the entrepreneur to synthesize it into a coherent whole.